Producers: Katie McNeill, Leopold Hughes and Ben LeClair Director: Noah Segan Screenplay: Noah Segan Cast: John Turturro, Giancarlo Esposito, Will Price, Tatiana Maslany, Steve Buscemi, Lori Tan Chinn, Kelvin Han Yee, Karina Arroyave, John Gallagher Jr., Victoria Moroles, Jack Mulhern, Michael Hsu Rosen, Aida Turturro, Mark Cayne, Michael Hsu Rosen, Lori Tan Chinn and Jamie Lee Curtis Distributor: Sony Pictures Classics
Grade: B
John Turturro has been doing stellar work for so long—his film career goes back to a bit part in “Raging Bull” nearly half a century ago, after all—that it’s become easy to take him for granted. Happily Noah Segan’s gritty, rather old fashioned character-study-cum-crime-thriller puts him at center stage, and he revels in the opportunity, giving a performance of nuance and depth.
Turturro plays Harry Lehmann, the petty criminal of the title, though as the last act of “The Only Living Pickpocket in New York” shows, he’s actually not the sole practitioner of the skill around. Harry is, however, definitely old school, a technophobe who finds the trade increasingly baffling, what with wallets without any cash in them, the ubiquitous credit cards easily locked even before they can be used. Other pilfered items, like watches and phones, no longer have much resale value, as Harry’s long-time fence, pawn shop owner Ben (Steve Buscemi), acidly informs him.
But Harry has little choice but to soldier on; he’s the sole support of his wife Rosie (Karina Arroyave), who’s been left comatose by illness and whom he cares for in their Bronx apartment with loving solicitude. He thinks his luck has changed when he notices an arrogant young fellow (Will Price) in an expensive tracksuit park his spotless vintage car, a blue 1969 Mustang, outside a bar. He bumps into the guy and pockets his wallet, taking time to make sure the driver’s door remains unlocked so he can circle back and relieve the back seat of a gym bag that contains more cash—but also a gun. Harry disposes of the bag and firearm in a nearby trashcan, but purloins a USB card from the wallet to Ben, whose ancient desktop can’t deal with it. He suggests that Harry walk it to a shop in Chinatown, where Frank (Kelvin Han Yee) can take it off his hands.
Harry’s luck, however, quickly runs out. His flashy mark, Dylan, is a mob kid, supremely well connected, and using surveillance cameras and Ben’s brief computer connection, he tracks Harry down, taking over his apartment with his crew. Harry has to return the USB card—which, it turns out, is Dylan’s crypto wallet—within hours, or Rosie will suffer the consequences.
That sends Harry on a desperate chase back to Frank’s and then to another shop run by his grandson Ernie (Michael Hsu Rosen), where he’s sent the card; only the intervention of Ernie’s grandma (Lori Tan Chinn) when Ernie refuses to help allows him to find it.
But before he returns it to Dylan, Harry has some business to attend to. He makes a side trip to visit his long-estranged daughter Kelly (Tatiana Maslany), who’s in no mood to hear him out. And realizing that, given the mob world into which he stumbled, his own life will probably be forfeit, he plans a scheme to protect Rosie that involves not just Ben but his tech-savvy daughter Eve (Victoria Moroles). He also makes provision not just for the astonished Kelly and the neighbor (Echaka Agba) who’s helped watch over Rosie, but for Detective Warren (Giancarlo Esposito), a cop as out-of-date as Harry, who’s proven himself more friend than foe.
Then Harry is taken for a ride, as they used to say, by the head of the mob outfit Dylan’s connected with, his grandmother Moira (Jamie Leigh Curtis), though only after a bit of a scuffle with Dylan. The two share reminiscences about old days in the Big Apple before a final stop that gives Turturro a poignant and powerful closing close-up.
Turturro is quietly astonishing throughout, presenting a haggard, slightly morose mien as he trudges around not just Manhattan but other boroughs wearing what amounts to his uniform, a well-kept old grey-and-white tweed overcoat with plenty of room for storing pilfered property (a perfect selection by costumer Cailey Breneman, as character-specific as Dylan’s snazzy tracksuit). He occasionally takes the subway—on one occasion running into Warren there, where they exchange pleasantries though Harry’s careful to sit on his hands to avoid any hint of suspicion on the cop’s part. But he prefers walking, and the long shots of his peregrinations make New York City a character in itself, captured in Sam Levy’s deliciously patient cinematography and Hilda Rasula’s editing, which makes good use of Rocío Giménez’s evocative production design.
The soundtrack is true to the city as well, not only in the cadences of the characters but the choice of music; the picture begins to the strains of LCD Soundsystem’s “New York, I Love You but You’re Bringing Me Down,” and other similarly spot-on needle drops punctuate Gary Lionelli’s faintly jazzy score until Bobby Short’s version of Cole Porter’s “I Happen to Like New York” shows up for the closing credits.
Which isn’t to say that the other actors, even those in small roles, don’t shine. Buscemi is terrific as the casually dyspeptic Ben, and Price makes Dylan the sort of arrogant, entitled young creep you love to hate. Arroyave and Maslany excel in their brief scenes as the women in Harry’s life, while Moroles is sassy and shrewd as Ben’s tech-savvy daughter and Curtis is a scene-stealer, even one-on-one with Turturro, as the cooly malevolent mob boss. (One can only wonder how Dylan will fare at her hands when she realizes what his stupidity has cost.) Among the rest, a virtual parade of superior character actors, one might note John Gallagher as the pushy businessman who’s Harry’s first mark.
There are times in the film when Segan’s direction goes a bit slack, and some longueurs when Rasula lingers over scenes that might have been trimmed. The twists of Harry’s scheme at the close aren’t presented crisply enough to avoid some confusion, and the sudden introduction of a character named Billy (Mark Cayne), who makes its success possible, comes across as a clumsy coincidence.
But the richness of Turturro’s performance, so shaded and heartfelt, makes any flaws trivial. Like Harry, Segan’s film may be a throwback, but in a good way.