Producers: Javier Calvo, Javier Ambrossi and Jorge Pezzi Directors: Javier Calvo and Javier Ambrossi Screenplay: Javier Calvo, Javier Ambrossi and Alberto Conejero Cast: Guitarricadelafuente, Miguel Bernardeau, Carlos González, Milos Quifes, Lola Dueñas, Alberto Cortés, Julio Torres, Albert Pla, Yenesi, Hugo Welzel, Mario Silvo, Mona Martínez, Antonio de la Torre, Natalia de Molina, Lorenzo Zurzolo, Nuria Mencía, María Morales, Javier Butler, Mateo Medina, Teo Lucadamo, Valentín Martínez, Juan Vergara, Gio Martínez, Joaquín Ruíz, Penélope Cruz and Glenn Close Distributor: Netflix
Grade: C+
This film by Javier Castro and Javier Ambrossi is an epic melodrama spanning the evolution of gay life in Spain over the course of nearly a century, using an unfinished play by Federico García Lorca to link its three acts. The triptych of tales, pieces of which are shuffled like playing cards throughout, makes for a distended, disjointed narrative in which the main theme of repeated martyrdom at the hands of a brutally bigoted society is magnified by the horror of civil war and its repressive aftermath. The symbol of choice is the black ball, la bola negra, that’s employed to ostracize those deemed different and therefore suspect, which is also the title of Lorca’s lost play, only a few pages of which are thought to have been completed when he was assassinated in 1936, which by implication is the fundamental act of secular martyrdom in the history being told.
Based on the 2015 play “La piedra oscura” by Alberto Conejero, with whom Calvo and Ambrossi collaborated on the screenplay, the film first toggles events of 1932 and 1937, the period during which the country was lurching into revolution and civil conflict, the establishment of the Second Republic leading to the war between the Republicans and the so-called Nationalists that raged until 1939 and ended in the fascist regime of Franco.
The chronologically earliest scenes are set in Granada in 1932, where Carlos (Milo Quifes), a young man from a wealthy family, is blackballed when he attempts to join the casino, or social club, to which his father (Antonio de la Torre) belongs. The reason for his rejection is suspicion of homosexuality, based on his friendship with Lorenzo (Mario Silvo) and Enrique (Hugo Welzel).
The suspicion is not groundless, as the night Carlos spends with Enrique after he’s accosted by a strange old woman (Mona Martínez) who claims he’s her murdered son proves. But when his father insists he resubmit his application, Carlos denies being gay before the assembled members; no sooner does he do so than the casino crumbles around them, the result of the attempted coup of that year.
But the film actually begins with a striking sequence set in 1937, when the residents of a small village devoted to the Nationalist cause in the civil war have assembled in the town square to welcome the arrival of Italian comrades sent by Mussolini to assist against the Republicans. Among them is Sebastián (Guitarricadelafuente), the shy, somewhat dim trumpeter in the band that begins to play enthusiastically as Italian planes approach.
Unfortunately, the planes strafe the town, killing most of the revelers. Sebastián manages to survive by fleeing into the demolished church, where he scrambles over the fallen statue of his namesake saint, pulling himself to safety by grabbing onto the arrows protruding from the stone martyr’s body. But his ordeal is not over: taken prisoner by Nationalist troops, he’s forced to join their ranks.
He’s assigned to guard Rafael Rodríguez Rapún (Miguel Bernardeau), a severely wounded Republican soldier taken prisoner in a recent battle. He’s also tasked with befriending the handsome footballer—one of the few characters here who actually existed—in order to extract information about enemy plans. But caring for Rodríguez Rapún awakens the gay yearning in Sebastián, and when the time comes for the prisoner’s execution, the doomed man, who had been the lover of García Lorca (Alberto Cortés) and chosen by the playwright to ensure the survival of his final work, asks him to assume the task even though he’s a member of the firing squad.
Jumping ahead to 2017, when legal prohibitions against homosexuality have been abolished, the film introduces Alberto López Azcuna (Carlos González), a failed playwright turned historical researcher living in Madrid with his ebullient partner Juan (Julio Torres), who receives notice of an inheritance from the grandfather he’s never met. Despite the insistence of his tempestuous mother Teresa (Lola Dueñas), from whom he’s long been estranged, that he ignore the gift from the father who’d long ago abandoned her, he travels to a small northern village to consult his grandfather’s elderly executor and heir Pascual (Albert Pla). Pascual presents him with an envelope that contains papers taking us back to the events of both 1932 and 1937.
Calvo, Ambrossi and Conejero have given “La bola negra” an extremely complex construction, but despite the effort to keep us in suspense with its chronological back-and-forths, the code that ties everything together isn’t hard to crack, given the title of García Lorca’s lost play, the plot of Carlos’ story, the trajectory of Sebastián’s, and what quickly emerges as the film’s overall theme. The directors’ operatic style, which includes a surrealistic conclusion to Carlos’ tale, and stellar contributions from their crew—cinematographer Gris Jordana, production designer Roger Bellés, costumer Ana López Cobos and editor Alberto Gutiérrez—nevertheless invest the film with epic sweep, even if it suffers from longueurs in the Sebastián sequence.
There are also digressions, like an episode—an extended cadenza, one might say– involving Penélope Cruz as Nené Romero, a flamboyant singer whom Sebastián encounters when she comes to entertain the troops. Another episode, featuring Glenn Close as a specialist in the work of García Lorca whose expertise proves essential in the last act, is more dutiful, but though rather clumsily presented (the explanation Close’s character, Isabelle Durand, offers for her devotion to the author is maudlin), it does its expository job.
One must note the strong performances of the leads, with Guitarricadelafuente, Bernardeau, González and Quifes all delivering soulful turns. Some of the supporting players (that of Dueñas, for instance) would have benefited from a modicum of restraint, but for the most part the cast serves the material well, though one must make an exception regarding Cortés’ affected turn as García Lorca, who comes off rather like a creepy cult leader. (The hagiographical way the directors choose to introduce him in flashback doesn’t help, shooting him from the back ss he addresses a group of admirers until he turns to look meaningfully at Rodríguez Rapún.) Raül Refree contributes a score that’s only occasionally overemphatic. (Cruz’s numbers certainly energize the proceedings.)
“La bola negra” is certainly an ambitious film that strives to encompass a century-long social revolution within its busily epic span; but the narrative complexity comes off tricky rather than revealing, and melodramatic excess undermines its undeniable power.