Producers: Mario Gianani, Lorenzo Mieli, Ewa Puszczyńska, Jeanne Tremsal, Edward Berger, Dimitri Rassam and Lorenzo Gangarossa Director: Pawel Pawlikowski Screenplay: Pawel Pawlikowski and Henk Handloegten Cast: Sandra Hüller, Hanns Zischler, August Diehl, Devid Striesow, Anna Madeley, David Menkin, Joachim Meyerhoff, Enno Trebs, Theo Trebs, Waldemar Kobus, Daniel Wagner, Fritzi Haberlandt, Milan Peschel and Joanna Kulig Distributor: MUBI
Grade: A-
In his two previous films, “Ida” (2013) and “Cold War” (2018), Polish writer-director Pawel Pawlikowski examined the Cold War era from deeply personal perspectives, capturing with exquisite care, in both narrative and visual terms, the experiences of individuals caught up in Eastern Europe during and after the period. With “Fatherland (Ojczyzna),” he considers the beginning of European division after the war in a fashion no less pictorially immaculate, but more historically based and intellectually focused.
The film offers a freely dramatized version of the trip Nobel Prize-winning novelist Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler) made to the divided Germany in the summer of 1949 to commemorate the two hundredth anniversary of Goethe’s birth. He was actually accompanied by his wife Katia, but in this telling it’s Mann’s daughter Erika (Sandra Hüller) who serves as his driver and amanuensis.
Though he had fled Germany in 1933 and been virulently anti-Nazi, he was equivocal about both western and eastern plans for postwar Germany, and looked upon his participation in events on both sides of the demarcation line as a means of encouraging the nation’s cultural reunification and rebirth. Mann is trying, in effect, to employ his renown to remake the old Germany he loved by appealing to what he sees as its literary and philosophical underpinnings; when asked where he calls home, he can says where he lives, but is inevitably drawn to discuss the concept of Heimat, that ineffable concept of an emotional homeland he desperately wants to recover through what he sees as his power of argument.
In depicting his doomed effort, the film accurately portrays his speech accepting the city’s Goethe Prize at Frankfurt am Main, Goethe’s birthplace in the recently established FRG in July, and his subsequent trip to Weimar, in the Soviet zone which would soon formally become the GDR, where the author had spent most of his life, in August. There he gave the identical speech and received a newly-created Goethe National Prize.
In fact the film uses the two events to emphasize Mann’s ambivalence about the so-called denazification program in West Germany and the imposition of Soviet-style communism in the East. At a reception in Frankfurt where an American official (David Menkin) effectively presides, he brutally rebuffs Wieland and Wolfgang Wagner (Enno and Theo Trebs), the grandsons of Hitler favorite Richard, who seek his support for the reopening of Bayreuth, and Erika confronts her former husband Gustaf Gründgens (Joachim Meyerhoff), an actor who had continued performing under Nazi rule, after whom her brother Klaus (August Diehl), a fervent anti-fascist, had fashioned the protagonist of his bitter novel “Mephisto” in 1936. A journalist (Anna Madeley) congratulates her, but emphasizes that her father’s decision to travel into the Soviet zone will be condemned back in America.
Nonetheless Thomas insists on continuing the trip, and they are warmly received both by Johannes Becher (Devid Striesow), the suave attaché who has arranged the trip with the goal of persuading Mann to accept a role in the new regime’s cultural establishment, and by Sergei Tiulpanov (Daniel Wagner), the brusquer head of Soviet military propaganda, who emphasizes the new ideological line and, as Mann learns from an intervention from a local activist (Milan Peschel), is rounding up dissidents for incarceration in the former Buchenwald concentration camp. After enduring elaborate festivities where the theme of the restoration of the Fatherland is emphasized, Mann, who has gone to great lengths to remain equable and inoffensive throughout while delivering the same hopeful message he had in Frankfurt, declines Becher’s invitation, suggesting his brother Heinrich instead.
The trip to Weimar has been clouded from the start by news the Manns had received in Frankfurt about the death, either by accident or suicide, of Klaus, and by Thomas’ decision not to break off the journey in order to return for the funeral in Cannes, leaving arrangements to his youngest son Michael. (Klaus’s death had actually occurred earlier in the year, when the Manns were touring Sweden before proceeding to Germany.)
Though Mann has tried to remain stoic in the face of Erika’s quiet desolation at the loss of her beloved brother, on the return trip to the west the two make an impromptu stop at a church—presumably either the chapel of Wartburg Castle or the church at Arnstadt, both of which they mentioned as being along their route while traveling east, and both associated with the young Johann Sebastian Bach. There they join hands and listen as an organist struggles with the blowsy instrument to play “Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring,” as the famous English version of the chorale from Bach’s cantata BMV 147 is known. (Erika recalls Klaus saying that Bach almost made him believe in God, to which her father, in typically erudite fashion, replies that he thought Nietzsche had said that about Beethoven.)
Shot in black-and-white and boxy academy format, “Fatherland” is visually impeccable, with each luminous frame given a painterly feel by cinematographer Lukasz Zal, who uses the Polish locations, the production design by Katarzyna Sobańska and Marcel Sławiński and Aleksandra Staszko’s unobtrusively period costumes to fullest effect. While letting sequences unfold at a leisurely pace Pawlikowski and his co-editor Piotr Wójcik nonetheless never lose their grip on audience attention, keeping the full running-time to an astonishingly short eighty-three minutes, including a long final credits roll.
And Pawlikowski has chosen his cast with care, finding in Hüller and Zischler performers who can encapsulate both Manns’ private and public personas to perfection and surrounding them with supporting players who can etch compelling figures in minimal screen time.
Despite its brevity this is a film rich in texture and meaning, portraying a horrendous family tragedy against the delusion of a man who believes that a past he cherishes can be reborn from the rubble of war by an appeal to reason and shared culture. As that final scene implies, the culture survived, unbowed if bruised, but the dream proved illusory.