F
Valerie Breiman is aiming for a hip, insightful romantic comedy in her debut feature, but “Love & Sex” is more like an R-rated live-action version of the “Cathy” comic strip stretched out to an excruciating ninety minutes. It boasts what’s less a script than a chain of one-liners, and they’re delivered by the stranded cast with all the subtlety of a sweaty, desperate stand-up comic who knows that he’s stuck with a rotten routine.
The central character is Kate Welles (Famke Janssen), an writer for a glossy woman’s magazine who’s unhappy in her personal life. Narrating the piece as she tries to work on an upbeat article, Kate tells us all about her failed attachments, starting with her first infatuation in elementary school and proceeding to the present; the emphasis is on her on-again, off-again relationship with Adam Levy (Jon Favreau), a supposedly talented painter with whom she enjoyed a long live-in period before they broke up (while remaining “friends”). The fundamental issue is whether the two will get back together despite the fact that each has moved on to others, she to a studly but dumb actor named Joey (John Hopkins) and he to a cheery Lolita type, Savannah (Kristen Zang). Truth to tell, there’s no surprise in the denouement. Unfortunately, there’s no fun in getting there.
That’s because everything in “Love & Sex” seems phony and forced, without a single instant that remotely resembles the real world. (The screenplay reaches its nadir in this respect when still-smitten Adam sends a bongo-playing dwarf to serenade Kate at her workplace with a message of reconciliation.) The cast is composed of able performers, but they seem totally at sea, an understandable reaction when confronted with such flimsy but overwritten material. Janssen is an attractive actress, but she’s hobbled by terrible dialogue (including that awful narration), and most of the time she’s forced to play glum. Favreau, by contrast, has energy aplenty, but he comes across as manic, with a deer-in-the-headlights look pribably explained by his realization that the lines he’s reciting are extraordinarily dumb. Ann Magnuson gets to do her bitchy shtick once more as Kate’s boss, and Cheri Oteri her overly exuberant routine as an office-mate. Noah Emmerich and Robert Knepper (who used to call himself “Rob”) are wasted as old boyfriends of our heroine. The only person who gets any smiles is John Hopkins, as the dense Joey Santino; but a viewer’s heart sinks when the screenplay compels him to repeat Robert De Niro’s “Taxi Driver” lines yet again. Can we please have a moratorium on the “You talking to me?” bit?
At one point in “Love & Sex,” the romantic couple argues over which video to rent for a night at home. Adam wants a porno action flick, but Kate insists on her favorite, Murnau’s “Nosferatu.” When Adam objects that watching it always makes her dejected and sullen, Kate explains, “I like to be depressed.” If that’s true, her desire can be easily fulfilled simply by viewing Breiman’s dismal little film.