Producer: Karen Rosenfelt Director: Jonathan Entwistle Screenplay: Rob Lieber Cast: Jackie Chan, Ralph Macchio, Ben Wang, Joshua Jackson, Sadie Stanley, Ming-Na Wen, Aramis Knight, Wyatt Oleff, Yankei Ge, Nicholas Carella, Tim Rozon, Shaunette Renée Wilson, Canecia Gordon and William Zabka Distributor: Sony/Columbia Pictures
Grade: C+
Fans of the “Karate Kid” franchise can rest easy: this “new” movie—the adjective should be taken with a grain of salt—doesn’t mess with the formula. The script by Rob Lieber (co-writer of “Peter Rabbit” and “Goosebumps 2”) follows the basic arc of the 1984 original–even starting off with a clip from 1986’s “The Karate Kid Part II—but tweaking it to embrace the worlds of both the 2010 remake and “Cobra Kai.” As an exercise in nostalgia for the initiated, it will prove a winner; as a stand-alone flick, however, the hurried, overstuffed picture comes disappointingly close to fit-for-streaming fare.
That’s not to deny the likability of the new version of “Daniel”—Ben Wang, who plays Li Fong, a Beijing kid who faces off against his Johnny Lawrence, Connor Day (Aramis Knight) after moving to New York with his mother (Ming-Na Wen), a doctor who’s taken a job in a NYC hospital. Her motive in moving across the world is grounded in the death of her older son (Yankei Ge), a kung fu champion who was killed by jealous rivals as Li looked on, petrified with fear. She hopes not only to give them both a chance at a new life, but to deter Li from continuing to train under shifu Han (Jackie Chan), getting him to promise to stop fighting in their new American home.
Li’s forced to abandon that pledge after he strikes up a friendship with Mia (Sadie Stanley), the sweet daughter of Victor Lipani (Joshua Jackson), the owner of a pizzeria down the street from the Li apartment. That earns him the hostility of Mia’s ex Connor, a local karate champion who gives him an unprovoked beatdown.
Still Li tries to avoid breaking his promise again until Victor is attacked by thugs and Li intervenes. The attackers were sent by O’Shea (Tim Rozon), the owner of the dojo where Connor trains and a loan shark to whom Victor owes lots of money. Li’s exhibition of his skill leads Victor, a former boxer, to ask the kid to train him for a tournament where the prize money could cover his debt. Li agrees, and the plan appears to be working until O’Shea plays a dirty trick and Victor winds up seriously injured.
But there’s an alternative: the Five Boroughs karate tournament, which carries a $50,000 prize, enough to cover Victor’s debt (and, perhaps, his hospital bill). It’s a long shot, but miraculously Han not only turns up at exactly the right moment to train Li, but enlists Daniel LaRusso (Ralph Macchio) to join him, using their shared reverence for Mr. Miyagi (Pat Morita) as inducement. Together they train Li in a mixture of kung fu and karate, the shifu and sensei explaining the result through the metaphor of one tree with two branches.
Naturally the culmination is the karate tournament which results in a championship bout between Li and Connor that, of course, goes down to the wire and concludes, as had that in the original “Kid,” with a special move: a flying kung fu kick his brother had mastered back in China but Li had never been able to. Now, under the guidance of Han and Daniel, he succeeds, adding a karate twist that proves decisive. He also, as Daniel had, exhibits true sportsmanship against an opponent who doesn’t know the meaning of the term. All’s right in the New York world—even Li’s mother has come around to her son’s dream—while a coda set in Los Angeles provides a “Cobra Kai” kicker as a further nod to the series’ fans.
As usual in this fare, “Legends” is positively replete with montages, both of New York sights and of Li’s training (especially of his finally mastering the special kick using a subway turnstile presided over by a frustrated guard played by Canecia Gordon). But director Jonathan Entwhistle (a TV veteran doing his first feature), working in tandem with his editors Colby Parker Jr. and Dana E. Glauberman, keeps things moving at a sprightly clip.
But while the ninety-four minute running-time is a relief after the bloated hundred-and-forty minute 2010 remake, all the plot turns and subplots mean that the movie has little room for character development; one expects Connor and O’Shea (who’s reduced to just a few nasty smirks) to be one-note villains, but apart from Li and Han, even the major figures get relatively short shrift (Macchio merely stands around for the most part, as though he had wandered in and stayed undirected).
Moreover, some sequences feel distinctly attenuated. In particular, the culminating karate tournament, set atop a skyscraper—a location cinematographer Justin Brown’s widescreen lensing takes full advantage of (and is one of the better moments in what is mostly a prosaic production design by Maya Sigel)—feels rushed, the preliminary rounds zoomed through without pause. But the final championship battle is at least captured in the detail it deserves, backed up by Dominic Lewis’ rousing score.
And if too many of the characters are little more than sketches, the cast do their best down the line, and both Wang, who was winning as the hero’s best buddy in Disney+’s pleasant “Chang Can Dunk,” and Chan are outstanding. The latter invests Han with his patented quizzical humor to excellent effect, while Wang manages to make even the guilt-trip aspect of Li a bit more than a plot crutch, choosing not to overplay the “closure” aspect of the finale. Stanley and Jackson haven’t much to do but smile and be genial, except for the bruising boxing match the latter endures, but both are amiable additions.
And one shouldn’t overlook engaging Wyatt Oleff as Alan, Li’s goofy math tutor, who offers his rooftop garden, complete with pet pigeons, as a training space. (It’s an inheritance, he explains in a throwaway line.) In lots of martial-arts movies the hero’s comic-relief best buddy gets badly beaten as a surrogate to the villain’s fury (remember the shellacking poor Evan Peters took in 2008’s “Never Back Down”—a role he’d probably rather forget?), but happily that doesn’t happen here: “Legends” is too good-natured for that, even if Victor’s boxing match is plenty nasty.
In sum, “Legends” probably does as well as one could hope in providing fan service for devotees of the first two movies, the 2010 remake and “Cobra Kai” while adding some new stuff, but cramming all that into ninety minutes makes for a bumpy ride despite Wang and Chan.