Producers: Dede Gardner, Jeremy Kleiner, Gabrielle Nadig, Nia DaCosta and Tessa Thompson Director: Nia DaCosta Screenplay: Nia DaCosta Cast: Tessa Thompson, Nina Hoss, Imogen Poots, Tom Bateman, Nicholas Pinnock, Kathryn Hunter, Finbar Lynch, Mirren Mack, Jamael Westman and Saffron Hocking Distributor: Orion Pictures/MGM Amazon Studios
Grade: B-
One glimpses the skeleton of Henrik Ibsen’s “Hedda Gabler” in Nia DaCosta’s “Hedda,” but it’s best to consider it an example of “inspired by” rather than “adapted from.” Purists will blanch at what they’ll consider disrespect of a classic whose title role has come to represent an Everest-high challenge for actresses to take up; others will appreciate the rejection of the stilted style that fidelity to the original has too often entailed. Though it has problems, DaCosta’s film certainly has flash and sizzle to spare.
That’s definitely true of Tessa Thompson’s vivid performance. In DaCosta’s revamping, Hedda is, of course, newly wed to wimpy academic George Tesman (Tom Bateman), but they’re not living in 1891 Norway but 1950s England, where they’re hosting a grand party on the estate that George impulsively purchased when Hedda, on a date, expressed a desire to live there; the purchase was enabled by financial help from Judge Brack (Nicholas Pinnock), an old friend of Hedda’s late father, an impecunious general, but has put George seriously in debt, a problem that he expects will be resolved by a promotion he’s in line for. That’s why it’s so important that Hedda cater to Professor Greenwood (Finbar Lynch), who controls the appointment and will be attending the bash along with his wife Tabitha (Mirren Mack), other academic colleagues, and a number of Hedda’s hedonistic friends.
Another attendee will be Eileen Lovborg (Nina Hoss), Hedda’s erstwhile lover, a recovering alcoholic and scholar in George’s field who’s written a book on sexual practices that’s become a best seller. Before she arrives, however, her current partner, mousy Thea Clifton (Imogen Poots), shows up looking for her. Feigning concern, Hedda dresses her appropriately for the party and insists she stay. When Eileen appears, she’s carrying the manuscript of a new book on the future normalization of more permissive sexual mores that’s sure to outsell its predecessor. She’s also become a candidate for the position George has based his hopes on.
This is a recipe for a combustible evening, particularly when one adds to the brew Judge Brack’s obsession with the manipulative Hedda, and the party that results has vicious fun and games that might make you think it’s the precursor to those in Edward Albee’s “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?” Backstabbing, betrayal, revelations and some gunshots are all part of the mix, with Hedda at the center of it all.
And Thompson is at the center of the melodrama, embodying Hedda’s scheming with flair, and her inevitable downfall with intensity. It doesn’t stand alone, however, being matched by the commanding performance of Hoss as the outwardly strong but actually fragile Lovburg; the change of gender from the play adds a new wrinkle to the mix, and Poots’s mousy exterior proves in the end no less deceptive than Hoss’s stern one.
The men are less impressive, though Pinnock’s Brack holds his own even against Hedda with an equal penchant for stealth and strategy. Bateman, however, is convincingly malleable as Hedda’s desperate husband and Lynch makes an insufferable academic prig—and cuckolded spouse.
DaCosta suffuses the film with style—arguably too much, as she did her reboot of “Candyman.” She exults in the dark interiors and lush, shadowy exteriors of the estate, courtesy of production designer Cara Brower, and in the luxurious period costumes of Lindsay Pugh. Even more notable is Sean Bobbit’s swooping cinematography, which swirls around the principals like a roving insect and indulges in tricks like Hedda’s glide toward Eileen as she enters the house; the effect works in tandem with Jacob Secher Schulsinger’s sharp but knowing editing. Then there’s Hildur Guðnadóttir’s jazzy, percussive score, heavy on drums and xylophones with an occasional smattering of hushed voices, which acts at times like an assault on the senses.
Purists will probably question, even deplore, what DaCosta has pulled off here. But on its own terms “Hedda” is a gripping reimagining of Ibsen’s naturalistic classic. Pity any student, however, who’s assigned to write an essay on the play and uses it as a pony.