Producers: Peter Safran and James Gunn Director: James Gunn Screenplay: James Gunn Cast: David Corenswet, Rachel Brosnahan, Nicholas Hoult, Edi Gathegi, Anthony Carrigan, Nathan Fillion, Isabela Merced, Skyler Gisondo, Sara Sampaio, María Gabriela de Faría, Wendell Pierce, Alan Tudyk, Pruitt Taylor Vince, Neva Howell, Beck Bennett, Mikaela Hoover, Zlatko Burić, Terence Rosemore, Frank Grillo, Dinesh Thyagarajan, Grace Chan, Sean Gunn, Michael Rooker, Pom Klementieff, Jennifer Holland, Bradley Cooper, Angela Sarafyan, Stephen Blackehart, Will Reeve, John Cena and Milly Alcock Distributor: Warner Bros.
Grade: B+
James Gunn proves just the man to inject a new burst of cinematic life into the Kryptonian Kal-El, aka Clark Kent, aka Superman, who since Christopher Reeve put on the obligatory red-and-blue tights and cape back in 1978, has stumbled on the big screen—though “Superman II” (1980) was at least the equal of the first film, Reeve’s third and fourth appearances in the role were duds, and while some of us still appreciate the grandeur and stateliness of Bryan Singer’s “Superman Returns” (2006), it was a financial disappointment.
Now Gunn has done for Superman what he previously did for the Suicide Squad—rescued him from the dark, heavy hand of the Zack Snyder era, which began with “Man of Steel” in 2013 and continued through “Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice” (2016) and “Justice League” (his version of which finally appeared in 2021). Gunn’s “Superman” is bright, exuberant, warmhearted fun, a genuine comic-book tale of the old school brought to vivid big-screen (really big-screen in IMAX terms) life, but done up with a modern sensibility.
Though arguably overstuffed with characters and subplots—most superhero series become cluttered over time, but you might call “Superman” pre-cluttered, since Gunn seems reluctant to leave any of his ideas out—it’s a reboot that’s also a revitalization, sparked by a new Man of Steel, David Corenswet, who makes him charmingly boyish as well as credibly idealistic but rather naïve, determinedly stalwart yet emotionally vulnerable. Corenswet is as winning in the role as Reeve was. It might be deemed heresy to say so, but he might actually be better than Reeve; at least he’s a better fit for Gunn’s version of Superman than Reeve would have been.
Gunn blithely dispenses with the backstory we all know from the books and movies with a brief chronology up front—Kal-El came to earth from the collapsing Krypton thirty years earlier, began his caped career in Metropolis three years ago, and now has suffered his first crushing defeat at the hands of a monstrous brute called the Hammer of Boravia; we first see him plummet to the frozen Arctic ground, bloodied and beaten.
Rescued by his “not so good” superdog Krypto (an absolute scene-stealer, and as major player here as he was in the animated “DC League of Super Pets”), Superman is tended to by chatty robots in his ice-palace Fortress of Solitude (Twelve is voiced by the ever-reliable Alan Tudyk), who treat him with a massive dose of yellow sunlight while soothing him with the only surviving clip of his Kryptonian parents to survive the crash of his spacecraft—a message about doing good and serving mankind. Restored, he flies back to Metropolis.
It’s a rather different place than what you might expect. The opening captions have already informed us that metahumans have been around for three hundred years—the city is staffed by a so-called Justice Gang composed of second-tier Green Lantern Guy Gardner (hilariously coiffed Nathan Fillion), mace-wielding Hawkgirl (spiky Isabela Merced) and tech brainiac Mr. Terrific (a really terrific Edi Gathegi).
And Superman’s alter-ego Clark, played by Corenswet as just a bit of a geek rather than Reeve’s hapless klutz, isn’t spending his time hiding his superhero identity from colleague Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan). Though they publicly spar in the newsroom in the sight of others, including young photographer Jimmy Olsen (an engaging Skyler Gisondo), sports guy Steve Lombard (Beck Bennett), svelte columnist Cat Grant (Mikaela Hoover), businesslike Ron Troupe (Christopher McDonald) and editor-in-chief Perry White (Wendell Pierce), they’re actually in a secret relationship, beautifully conveyed in an impromptu “interview” in which Lois, played with enormous verve by Brosnahan—no damsel-in-distress figure she, but a smart and savvy partner—warns earnest but over-confident Superman-Clark that his impulsive do-goodism might get him into trouble.
That brings matters back to the Hammer of Boravia, whose despot President Ghurkos (Zlatko Burić, all wild hair and preening disdain) had attempted an invasion of a neighboring country Superman had foiled, on his own without governmental authorization; the Hammer was his instrument of revenge.
But Ghurkos is not acting on his own—which brings us to the chief conflict in the story, the insatiable envy and hatred of Superman by Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult), long the evil mainstay of Superman mythology. In the Reeve films in which Luthor appeared, his conflict with the Man of Steel was mostly pragmatic, and depicted with a light hand, displayed in Gene Hackman’s lip-smacking performance and his vaudeville routine with goofy sidekick Otis (Ned Beatty). Here the enmity is deeply personal, and there’s nothing even remotely humorous in Hoult’s portrayal, which comes closer to Kevin Spacey’s vicious version in “Superman Returns.” There’s pure hatred here, combined with power and influence Luthor that cunningly uses in his determination to destroy the Man of Steel; and there’s an Otis (Terence Rosemore), but he’s no slapstick figure, merely one of Luthor’s skilled technicians.
Luthor breaks into the Fortress of Solitude, where he and his henchwoman the Engineer Angela Spica (intense María Gabriela de Faría), a literal human buzz saw, leave a mess, take a prisoner, and learn something Luthor can use to turn the tide of public opinion against Superman—and to cause Clark to doubt who he’s really meant to be. That leads to the Man of Steel’s turning himself into the authorities, ever honest and respectful of law, and being imprisoned in an under-the-radar “pocket universe” created by Luthor, who keeps all his foes there and now uses the inevitable kryptonite provided by a captive Metamorpho (Anthony Carrigan)—and other despicable means—to torture Superman and extract information from him.
That can’t be allowed to end things, of course, and so with help from friends—Lois and Mr. Terrific in particular, but also Metamorpho, as played by Carrigan a sweet fellow who overcomes his fears, he escapes, and with Krypto at his side faces Luthor in a final confrontation. The mogul throws everything he has at Superman, one foe after another, and time after time the Man of Steel seems on the verge of defeat; a viewer might feel as exhausted by the multiple climaxes as he is. But he never gives up. And—no spoiler here—he emerges victorious with his reputation restored, thanks not just to his valor but the efforts of Lois, Jimmy, and an unlikely ally in Eve Teschmacher (Sara Sampaio), a voluptuous broad with a yen for someone you might not expect. Luthor winds up as hated as he’d hoped to make Superman.
But that’s not all. Ghurkos has seized the opportunity to restart his invasion, and since Superman is otherwise engaged, other friends take up the slack—in particular the Justice Gang, which the vainglorious Gardner pointedly refers to as an upgrade.
Optimism is at the root of Gunn’s vision—whatever the forces arrayed against Superman’s innate goodness, he prevails, helped by his equally principled friends. And as to finding himself, he does so in the midst of apparent failure, thanks to loving support not only from Lois but from his adoptive parents Jonathan and Marta (Pruitt Taylor Vince and Neva Howell), whose raising of Clark is only alluded to in brief snippets but nonetheless prove decisive in a final scene back at the Fortress where Superman is convalescing after his exertions. This is basically an uplifting tale, predictably enough, of the triumph of virtue over vice, one that, like all of the Superman stories over the years, celebrates the alien hero’s innate sense of goodness, demonstrated in, as Jonathan sagely says, choices and deeds rather than place of origin; in one scene Superman pauses to save a dog and a squirrel during a battle, and when he tries to capture a monster rather than just kill it, Green Lantern dismisses him with “Don’t be a wuss.” But of course, that sense of compassion is central to the character, and Gunn embraces it.
What’s remarkable about Gunn’s “Superman” is that it manages to be both reverent and irreverent, flippant and sincere, respectful of the comic canon yet unafraid to toy with it. It’s filled with references to earlier Superman lore—you can glimpse shout outs not only to the Donner, Lester, Singer and even Snyder films, but to TV incarnations, especially “Smallville” and the animated series (including the recent “My Adventures with Superman”). And to comics, of course—not only the recent ones (Gunn has cited “All Star Superman” as a special influence), but the gloriously silly ones of the so-called Silver Age, which some of us are old enough to remember reading as kids.
Yet it’s not stuck in the past. The humor is often of the snarky variety Gunn mastered in “Guardians of the Galaxy,” toned down for family consumption (Four has a great throwaway in a muted desire to be called Gary), and one can’t miss references to today’s realities—immigration, to be sure, and international turmoil. But they’re not treated in a crudely didactic fashion, and are often conjoined with a loopy reference (Luthor’s deal with Ghurkos points back to his West Coast plans in Donner’s movie), or to outrageous exaggeration (Luthor’s purveyors of social media accusations against Superman are literally trained monkeys).
And while Gunn is committed to the canon, he’s not afraid to tweak it. In their interview scene early on, Lois chides Clark for his disguise—a pair of glasses—to keep people from identifying him as Superman, a joke we all get. But later Gardner points out what Lois already knows—they’re hypno glasses, which make Clark look significantly different in an observer’s eyes. It’s not a Gunn invention, but it’s one many viewers won’t know in advance.
All of which wouldn’t matter a whit if the movie weren’t mounted with remarkable expertise. The production design (Beth Mickle) and costuming (Judianna Makovsky) are exceptional, and Henry’s Braham’s bright cinematography showcases them beautifully; editors William Hoy and Craig Alpert keep things moving at a good clip, even when the action slows down for introspection or exposition, and the top-flight visual effects (executed by a huge team supervised by Stephane Ceretti) are integrated well into the live-action. John Murphy and David Fleming contribute a fine score that pays ample tribute to John Williams’ iconic one; even the credits design is a bow to the past.
Devoted fans will mostly love ”Superman” for its fan service and obvious affection (unless, of course, they’re members of the perpetually dyspeptic Snyder cult), and while others may be less enthusiastic, they should also find it a treat despite its jam-packed content and hectic pace—it comes in, even with credits and added scenes (which you’re advised not to skip) at only a bit over two hours, short by superhero standards. It may not restore your optimism about the fate of the real world in these days of prevailing uncertainty, but it does restore your faith that superhero movies can still be rousingly enjoyable—and your hope that the planned new DCU can maintain the standard it establishes.
Your move, Marvel.