Producers: Jonathan Eirich and Dan Lin Director: Dean Fleischer Camp Screenplay: Chris Kekaniokalani Bright and Mike Van Waes Cast: Maia Kealoha, Sydney Elizabeth Agudong, Chris Sanders, Billy Magnussen, Zach Galifianakis, Tia Carrere, Courtney B. Vance, Kaipo Dudoit, Amy Hill, Hannah Waddingham, Jason Scott Lee, Celia Kenney, Brutus Labenz, Skyler Bible, Judy Nguyen and Christian Yeung Distributor: Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Grade: C
Disney’s 2002 animated “Lilo & Stitch,” about a Hawaiian orphan girl who adopted a rambunctious outer-space critter, had a lot of charm and turned into a media franchise; this new one, the latest cog in Disney’s program to plunder its beloved IP in “live-action” (actually half live-action, half animated) remakes, retains too little of it. It’s a particular disappointment coming from director Dean Fleischer Camp, whose “Marcel the Shell with Shoes On” (2021) exhibited a degree of imagination this big-budget follow-up sorely lacks.
The script, ascribed to Chris Kekaniokalani Bright and Mike Van Waes, hews quite closely to the original—slavishly one might say—in most respects but makes some tweaks that either spring from the “live action” part of the equation or are simply needless additions. A computer-animated prologue basically repeats that of the original: Stitch (again voiced by Chris Sanders, who co-wrote and directed the 2002 movie with Dean DeBlois) is revealed as the creation of mad scientist Jumba Jookiba (here Zach Galifianakis). He’s sentenced to exile by the imperious leader of the Galactic Federation (Hannah Waddingham) but escapes and crash lands on earth, so Jumba is enlisted to go and retrieve him, accompanied by the federation’s goofy earth expert Pleakley (Billy Magnussen).
Then we’re introduced to the now live-action earthlings, including six-year-old Lilo Pelekai (Maia Kealoha) and her older sister Nani (Sydney Elizabeth Agudong), orphans struggling to stay together under the sympathetic but watchful gaze of social worker Mrs. Kekoa (Tia Carrere)—a new character here, developed especially, one assumes, for Carrere, who voiced the animated Nani in 2002. Stitch’s arrival as the “dog” Lilo adopts doesn’t help matters, given his penchant for destructive mischief.
But their neighbor David (Kaipo Dudoit; Jason Scott Lee, who voiced the character in 2002, is now reduced to a cameo as one of Nani’s bosses), a neighbor boy with a crush on Nani, tries to be helpful, as does his grandmother Tūtū (Amy Hill), a new character designed to provide further comic relief—consider her the intrusive but lovable oldster, a familiar sitcom trope. Not new, but significantly altered, is Mr. Bubbles (Courtney B. Vance), the social worker of the original who’s now a CIA agent stalking Stitch, though he poses as Kekoa’s superior.
Also tracking Stitch, of course, are the bumbling Jookiba and Pleakley, who don’t merely try to disguise themselves, badly, as earthlings, as in the original, but actually assume human form. That gives Galifianakis and Magnussen the chance to do a lot of slapstick stuff deriving from their clumsy efforts to make their new bodies perform as they wish, but though the two give the jerkiness and pratfalls the old college try, the result is more aggravating than amusing.
Those who love its predecessor will be happy to know that in most respects this new “Lilo” follows the basic beats of the earlier movie, with plenty of hectic action and manufactured warmth mixed in. But it all feels second-best. Stitch—who’s computer animated throughout—looks a bit more like the koala bear that was the critter’s inspiration, but in this more tactile, “realistic” form he’s creepier than the original, done in what was then old-fashioned animation style, was. And as played by a real girl, Lilo is less unrestrained than she was in animated form; she’s a more poignant figure. The same can be said of Nani. What remains in the end, of course, is the emphasis on Ohana, or family in an extended sense, which is the essence of the culminating happy ending in both films, though here it’s made heavier with some technologically advanced addenda as well as expanded roles for Bubbles and Tūtū in the familial ensemble.
All of this isn’t to say that the 2025 “Lilo & Stitch” won’t be enjoyable for kids coming to the story for the first time, or familiar with it from its many variants since 2002. And adults who recall the original fondly but haven’t revisited it since its release will probably find it agreeable, if hardly a classic. Kealoha and Agudong are certainly likable, and the supporting cast is mostly fine, though Galifianakis looks a bit ill-at-ease. If not the gorgeous thing the animated version was, the picture is visually more than decent, thanks to the attractive locations, Todd Cherniawsky’s production design, Wendy Chuck’s costumes, Nigel Bluck’s cinematography and the army of animation and effects talent. Editor Philip J. Bartel keeps things moving at a reasonable clip, even if the final product runs nearly a half-hour longer than its model, and Don Romer contributes a bouncy score.
But despite the efforts of a committed cast and crew, this return to one of the company’s better modern animated efforts is an also-ran; it’s actually reminiscent of that mediocre 2009 kids-and-extraterrestrials live-action and computer-animated combo “Aliens in the Attic” (a movie Austin Butler might prefer to forget having appeared in). If not as misguided as the recent “Snow White,” this “Lilo & Stitch” comes off as just another of Disney’s unnecessary “live-action” remakes, destined to be forgotten while the original remains the go-to version.