Producer: Gabrielle Dumon Director: Laura Piani Screenplay: Laura Piani Cast: Camille Rutherford, Pablo Pauly, Charlie Anson, Annabelle Lengronne, Liz Crowther, Alan Fairbairn, Lola Peploe, Alice Butaud, Roman Angel, Laurence Pierre, Alyzée Soudet, Rodrigue Pouvin, Nina Hédin, Pierre-François Garel and Frederick Wiseman Distributor: Sony Pictures Classics
Grade: B-
The title suggests that Laura Piani’s feature debut might be designed to upend the conventions—some might say clichés—in Jane Austen’s novels, but in fact “Jane Austen Wrecked My Life,” which earns its double-language title from the fact that its characters slip back and forth between French and English, winds up basically conforming to them. That’s okay, of course, though one might wish it did so a bit more cleverly.
The life in question is that of Agathe Robinson (engaging Camille Rutherford), who works at Paris’ famous English-language bookstore Shakespeare & Company. She’s an aspiring writer, though unable to finish any of her stories, and is criticized by her writing teacher for concentrating on producing cheap romance novels. As to her life, she’s single, living in a small apartment with her sister Mona (Alice Butaud) and Mona’s young son Tom (Roman Angel). Mona’s a free-spirited sort: she can’t even be bothered to remember the name of the fellow (Pierre-François Garel) she’s shared her bed with the previous night with and brings to the breakfast table—it’s not Gabriel but Raphael, or is it the other way around?
Agathe’s personal life, on the other hand, is more staid. Frisky Félix (Pablo Pauly), her fellow clerk, flirts with her, but he’s a compulsive womanizer, and she adheres to a higher idea of romance. But she realizes that, as with her writing hopes, her opportunities might be fading. When Félix asks her which Austen heroine she identifies with, she says Anne Elliot from “Persuasion,” who, to paraphrase Oscar Hammerstein, let her golden chances pass her by when she broke off her engagement to Captain Wentworth. She’s also, we’ll eventually learn, hobbled by trauma: her parents were killed in a car accident in which she was only injured, and she bears both grief and a measure of undeserved guilt.
Both she and Félix soldier on in their own ways, however; she’s suddenly inspired to begin a novel in English about a sultry dream she had while eating alone in a Chinese restaurant, and when Félix surreptitiously reads the beginning chapter, he secretly puts in an application for her at a Jane Austen Writers’ Residency in England, where she’d have the opportunity to devote herself to the book. Naturally she’s accepted, and after some hemming and hawing is induced to go.
There she meets Oliver (Charlie Anson), Austen’s great-great-great-grandnephew, who’s reluctantly assumed responsibility for running the program started by his father Todd (Alan Fairbairn) and mother Beth (Liz Crowther); Todd is showing signs of dementia, and Beth, while utterly committed, is getting on. So Oliver has stepped into the breach, though his heart isn’t in it.
At first Agathe and Oliver don’t hit it off at all; indeed, stepping off the ferry she almost immediately throws up on his shoes when she sees his car (she has a phobia about riding in them). It doesn’t help that she loves Austen and he’s a university professor specializing in modern literature who disparages his ancestor’s books. But of course the chilliness dissipates over time, even after Agathe blunders naked into his room in a scene worthy of a French bedroom farce, and they find themselves falling in love—until Félix shows up unexpectedly, announces he’s a changed man in love with Agathe, and takes her home. Of course, if you know your Austen, you know that resolution won’t stand.
There are plenty of good things in the film. Rutherford, pretty in an unconventional way, makes a heroine who’s easy to root for, often awkward but obviously intelligent, even if her writer’s block persists through the whole residency (it will finally be broken only after she returns to her parents’ house and faces her grief). Pauly can be irritatingly pushy but shows he has a good heart after all, and Anson makes a likable Darcy surrogate, his pomposity gradually giving way to doe-eyed devotion. Fairbairn and Crowther are delightful, though his wide-eyed eccentricities become a bit much. And a couple of the other writers-in-residence—Annabelle Lengronne as Chéryl, who has a knack for fortune-telling that proves prophetic, and Lola Peploe as Olympia, an opinionated woman whom Agathe comforts at a crucial moment—have moments in the sun. Young Angel does as well. And it’s a nice touch to feature documentarian Frederick Wiseman in a cameo at the close.
The picture is attractive to look at, too. The locations, both in France and in the “English” settings (recreated on the continent, it seems) are quite lovely, and Agnès Sery’s production design makes the Austen house a place one might like to visit. Costumer Flore Vauville’s work is overall fine, but especially impressive in a “ballroom” scene toward the close, where Piani stages a cheeky pas de trois. Cinematographer Pierre Mazoyer makes even the more claustrophobic sets work fairly well (the opening scenes, notably, were actually shot at Shakespeare & Company), while editor Floriane Allier has kept the running-time under a hundred minutes. Peter Von Poehl’s original music evinces a suitably longing tone, but it might be time for French filmmakers to stop resorting to Schubert piano music whenever they’re after soulful melancholy. It’s become rather a cliché.
Piani’s debut reflects the spirit of an Austen novel without simply resorting to clumsy mimicry. The result is pleasantly familiar but with a distinctive spin.