Producers: Matt Reeves, Lynn Harris, James Gunn and Peter Safran Director: James Watkins Screenplay: Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini Cast: Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, Max Minghella, David Dencik, Eddie Marsan, Joana Ribeiro, Joshua James, Nancy Carroll, Sam Hazelbine, Jack Curran, Wil Coban and Rob Brydon Distributor: Warner Bros. Pictures
Grade: D
It hasn’t taken long for James Gunn’s DCU, which began with last year’s bright, upbeat “Superman,” to descend to the murky depths with this body-horror misfire based on a minor villain in the Batman pantheon of ne’er-do-wells. “Clayface” literally sinks into the Gotham City sewer before adding an astonishingly misguided coda that throws any notion of morality into the trash heap.
Tom Rhys Harries, who from some perspectives resembles a young Ed Begley, Jr., plays Matt Hagen, an actor on the cusp of matinee-idol fame. He’s just received an Oscar nomination, to the joy of his cynical agent (Eddie Marsan), publicist (Nancy Carroll) and best buddy, aspiring actor Corey Bowery (Joshua James).
But Matt makes a terrible error when he goes out to a nightclub to celebrate. He accepts an offer from sultry vixen Mia (Joana Ribeiro) to join her on the dance floor, as well as a pill that she passes from her tongue to his. Cut to his room the next morning, where the two are awoken by her possessive boyfriend, mob boss Markos Szabo (David Dencik), who orders his thugs to slash Matt’s face horribly in the first of the movie’s garishly explicit scenes of torn flesh and streaming blood.
One might think that Matt has a basis for a damage claim, but Markos is well connected—everybody seems to be in his thrall—and Mia’s claim that she was the one drugged and misused is widely believed. Matt ends up penniless in a squalid flat in his slummy old Gotham neighborhood, his life shattered and his career over.
In desperation he seeks out Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie), whose revolutionary nano-technological medical research has been undercut by investors who ended their funding and stole her results. He begs her to inject his face with the little AI critters in hopes they’ll restore his handsome features. She initially resists, but reluctantly agrees. The result is wonderfully efficacious.
For a while, that is. His face reverts without warning to a rubbery mass that he must deal with via scissors and tweezers (a scene in an airplane lavatory during some awful turbulence is especially unnerving). He helps himself to more injections, leading to his being able to transform himself into duplicates of other people when under mental stress.
That power comes in handy when he discovers that he was betrayed by his agent and even good old Corey, as well as Mia and Markos. That turns the movie into a revenge tale, with some pretty gruesome death sequences not only at his hands but via other portions of his oozy anatomy. (The end of Corey, via an enveloping device Clayface has used in the comics and animated TV series, is agreeably, and uniquely, bloodless.)
Those individual killings, though, are but the prelude to the pièce de résistance, Matt’s elaborate, protracted assault on Mia and Szabo at the latter’s nightclub. This involves Szabo’s small army of thugs (the most important of them Sam Hazelbine, Jack Curran and Wil Coban), a couple of whom Matt impersonates over the course of the slaughter.
His transformations, incidentally, are done in extremely simple fashion. Sometimes they require chintzy GCI work on Matt’s slushy face, but more often they’re simple superimpositions of one actor over another. And when it comes to the big finale, director James Watkins, cinematographer Rob Hardy and editor Jon Harris resort to one of the oldest tricks in the book, situating a pillar in the scene behind which one actor walks, only to have another emerge on the other side. (Recall, for instance, the famous sequence in the 1960 Twilight Zone episode “The Howling Man,” where a man gradually turns into the devil by that means.)
The obvious official corruption in Matt’s case, meanwhile, has caught the attention of John Bonnelli (Max Minghella), a straight-arrow cop who’s also Corr’s long-time fiancé. Since Matt is falling for her big-time, that makes John both an ally of Matt in the actor’s quest for justice and his rival in the romantic department. Gradually, though, Bonnelli’s interest in Matt’s crime spree causes a rift that leads to that awful coda in which all is forgiven in the name of love and the possibility of sequels is established.
The cast do what little they can with this material. Harries emotes most strenuously throughout; it probably would have been better to tone things down. Ackie too is deadly serious when a bit of humor—like those Minghella and Marsan provide—would have helped. But then it’s doubtful anyone could have done much with the dialogue by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, which is laughably clichéd, as if it came from the pages of a third-rate comic book. Everyone else also suffers from the necessity of having to put across dreadful lines as though they were golden. The only person to survive is comedian Rob Brydon; he plays a TV talk show host appropriately named Crassner, who for some reason Matt sees as himself in a mirror at one point late in the film. Brydon’s return makes no sense, but his high energy makes it welcome nonetheless.
This is a relatively cheap movie by DCU standards, and James Price’s production design looks it. Keith Madden’s costumes are nothing to write home about, either, while Volker Bertelmann’s score is same old, same old.
If you’re feeling generous, you might compare “Clayface” with “The Invisible Man” as the story of a protagonist driven murderously mad by an unwise use of science. But Watkins’ movie has none of the wit or style of James Whale’s 1933 classic. And Harries is no Claude Rains, who dominated the screen even though you couldn’t see him. It would also be generous to suggest that this mixture of gore, gloom and grime was designed to be taken as a comedy; unfortunately, the laughs, while definitely earned, seem to be of an unintentional variety.
The only thing satisfying about “Clayface” is that it’s hard to imagine the DCU sinking any lower.