Producers: Phillip Braun, Javier Chapa and Jon Silk Director: Felipe Vargas Screenplay: Alan Trezza Cast: Emeraude Toubia, José Zúñiga, Diana Lein, Emilia Faucher, Paul Ben-Victor, David Dastmalchian, Constanza Gutierrez, Nick Ballard, Luna Baxter and Guillermo Garcia Distributor: Mucho Mas Media
Grade: C
This is essentially just a jump-scare horror flick, but it’s given a patina of seriousness by a thread about the lengths to which immigrants will go to reach the U.S. and provide their children with a chance to succeed, and the children’s tendency to ignore their debt to the previous generation when they do.
Alan Trezza’s script begins in 1999 Brooklyn, where young Rosario Fuentes (Emilia Faucher) is being feted with a party on the day of her first communion; her joyful father Oscar (José Zúñiga) has invited all his friends and relatives for the festivities, but amidst the pleasantries her mother Elena (Diana Lein) is obviously ill, and her unsmiling crone of a grandmother Griselda (Constanza Gutierrez) is hostile—and mysteriously wounded.
Cut to the present, and Rose (Emeraude Toubia), as she now calls herself, is a successful, upscale New York stockbroker. She’s on reasonably good terms with Oscar, having chosen to live with him when her parents divorced. But Elena has since died, and Rose is estranged from Griselda, whom she rarely visits and whose calls she avoids taking.
Rose receives a call at work one day from Marty (Paul Ben-Victor), the super at Griselda’s run-down apartment building, who tells her that her grandmother has died and a family member should be present when the ambulance arrives to remove the body, which he and Griselda’s across-the-hall neighbor Joe (David Dastmalchian) have placed on a couch. After calling her father, she braves an incoming snowstorm to reach the building, where the elevator doesn’t work and the electricity flickers on and off sporadically. Marty is a surly type who criticizes her for not visiting the old lady more often, while Joe is shy—Marty says he’s ill—and seems interested only in retrieving an air fryer Griselda had borrowed.
The apartment is a wreck, and the sight Griselda’s gruesome corpse is frightening in the moonlight; Rose has to settle in for a long wait as the blizzard rages outside and the ambulance is delayed. There are spooky noises and inexplicable occurrences, like sudden apparitions (disembodied hands, creepy-crawly things) and appearances by the spirit of Elena, with whom Rose tries to make peace. Investigating the place, she finds a secret tunnel behind a closet door that contains the paraphernalia of the religion that Griselda practiced—Palo, an eclectic mixture of African tradition, Catholicism and Spiritism widespread in Cuba but also found in Mexico, which, an opening caption informs us, is typical in having aspects of light and darkness. Rose uses her laptop to research the religion—her findings are helpfully passed along to those of us who are unfamiliar with it—and comes to suspect that Griselda used it to influence her life, even perhaps to lay a curse on her.
The horror escalates exponentially as Oscar finally arrives at the apartment, as also does Kobayende, a powerful spirit god in the Palo mythology; their presence is the catalyst for revelations about Rosario’s past and the efforts exerted by her family to protect her, both during the harrowing crossing of the border and after they reach relative safety in New York. In the process the roles that Griselda, Oscar and Elena played are made clear, and Rose must come to terms with and learn from them.
All of that, this is presented through the horror tropes director Felipe Vargas relies on throughout, most—like the worms, maggots and crawling hands—realized through practical effects, though CGI is employed in the apparitions. The film, shot in Colombia aside from a few New York exterior shots, boasts a gloomy, sinister look via Carlos Osorio’s production design and Carmen Cabana’s cinematography, which among other elements includes some complex steadicam tracking shots, like the elaborate trip through the opening communion festivities. But despite the twists in the final reel, the plot is overall a pretty threadbare affair, and Vargas and editor Claudio Castello find it difficult to maintain tension even over a brief running-time. The score by Will Blair and Brooke Blair hits the many jump scares of figures popping up from outside the frame or behind the principals in the obvious ways.
This is in largely a one-woman show, and Toubia carries things quite well, bringing considerable intensity to a character who could have been more fully written; she has trouble pulling off the abrupt turn Rosario takes at the very close. Ben-Victor and Dastmalchian fail to instill Marty and Joe with the creepiness that’s obviously intended, but Zúñiga, Lein and Gutierrez manage to catch the shifting personas of Rose’s elder family members.
Except for its use of an unusual religion, Palo, to drive the plot, “Rosario” is a fairly conventional exercise in confined-space horror marked by a heavy use of jump scares. But its reference to immigrant experience does give it some added heft, even if that plot element isn’t handled in a particularly deep way.