Producers: Marty Bowen, John Fischer and Wyck Godfrey Director: Eli Craig Screenplay: Carter Blanchard, Adam Cesare and Eli Craig Cast: Katie Douglas, Aaron Abrams, Carson MacCormac, Vincent Muller, Kevin Durand, Will Sasso, Verity Marks, Cassandra Potenza, Ayo Solanke, Alexandra Martin Deakin, Jean-Jacques Javier, Daina Leitold and Bradley Sawatzky Distributor: RLJE Films/Shudder
Grade: C
Given its title, you might expect “Clown in a Cornfield,” with the obvious mash-up possibilities of “It” and “Children of the Corn,” to be played as high camp, but though Eli Craig’s movie is clearly indebted to the teen slasher flicks of the eighties, it’s more homage than spoof. It’s jocular in many respects to be sure, but the humor doesn’t cross into “how ridiculous is this rubbish?” territory, even in a last reel one might be inclined to chortle over. The genre might be absurd, but in a strange way the movie takes it seriously. Perhaps that’s because it’s an adaptation of a 2020 YA novel by Adam Cesare, who actually has a reputation in the horror field.
The setting is a typical American small town, Kettle Springs, Missouri (here portrayed by the Winnipeg area in Manitoba). A prologue set in 1991 shows a couple of randy, drunken teens from a party at the Baypen Corn Syrup Factory outside town traipsing into the surrounding cornfield, where they’re killed by a figure hidden in the rustling stalks, the boy hoisted high on a pitchfork.
Now Glenn Maybrook (Aaron Abrams) arrives with his daughter Quinn (Katie Douglas) to relocate his medical practice from the east to Kettle Springs. Quinn is unhappy with both the move and their dilapidated old house, but aims to make the best of things, and she gets some immediate support when Rust (Vincent Muller), an awkward but kindly neighbor boy, arrives to walk her to her first day at the local school.
In the rowdy class presided over by peevish Mr. Vern (Bradley Sawatzky) she meets the group she’ll hang out with: saucy blonde Janet (Cassandra Potenza) and her pal Ronnie (Verity Marks), Ronnie’s hunky boyfriend Matt (Alexandre Martin Deakin) and his goofy bud Tucker (Ayo Solanke), and cute rich kid Cole (Carson MacCormac), whose family founded the Baypen business that’s still the town’s sole claim to fame. In fact, Kettle Springs holds an annual parade in honor of the outfit’s mascot, Frendo the Clown, who’s also featured in little jack-in-the-boxes that pop up all over the place.
These kids engage in typical teen hijinks, like causing a ruckus in Otis’ (Jean-Jacques Javier) general store so they can cadge some booze. And they’ve taken to the web to post mini-slasher movies with Frendo as the killer. But one would hardly think them the sort of existential threat to local well-being described by the likes of Sheriff Dunne (Will Sasso), or Trudy (Daina Leitold), the waitress at the local diner, or Cole’s own father, Mayor Hill (Kevin Durand).
Moreover, they become the targets when Frendo actually appears—first glimpsed by Quinn in the background of one of those slasher posts—with slice-and-dice tools in hand. The practical death effects that follow are awfully cheesy, whether it’s because of a low budget or the desire to hew to 1980s models. But in this day when gallons of fake blood and mountains of grisly gore are what horror movies usually offer, the restraint, whatever the reason, is actually kind of refreshing.
But however much good will that might bring, it’s squandered in the protracted last act, which offers one of the silliest, most outlandish revelations in the history of slasher movies—which is saying something, given the absurdities that the genre succumbed to as it decayed. A near-death sequence that goes on long after the intended victim would have expired, but emerges unscathed, is dumb enough, but even it is exceeded by the inanity of the explanation the verbose villain gives for all the mayhem. A revelation regarding Rust is presumably intended to add a note of modern enlightenment to the ending, but feels like prefabricated pandering to current social norms.
Douglas nevertheless emerges as a spunky last girl standing, and while most of the other youngsters are just adequate, MacCormac has a twinkle in his eye that telegraphs a decision to play Cole tongue-in-cheek; he even manages to get through that awful finale. In any event, the kids are far superior to the adults, most of whom—Durand, Sasso and Sawatzky are the worst offenders, but the others aren’t far behind—are simply dreadful. The sole exception is Abrams, who pulls off the sad sack, Jason Segel/Daniel Stern-style doofus well enough. Technically this is a pretty threadbare effort, but production designer Brian Kane and cinematographer Brian Pearson have done what they could with the meager materials at hand, and one probably shouldn’t blame editor Sabrina Pitre for the fact that the finale drags badly. The score by Brandon Roberts and Marcus Trumpp does its job.
Those who recall the teen slasher movies of forty years ago with affection may get a kick out of this virtual tribute to them, but despite a couple of likable youngsters in the leads, the ludicrous last act proves fatal in one too many ways.