More Reviews

Reviews by Dr. Frank Swietek   

Instantly watch from thousands of TV episodes & movies streaming from Netflix. Try Netflix for FREE!

 

 

SOME GIRL(S) 
B 
Producer  Patty West, Chris Schwartz and Andrew Carlberg 
Director  Daisy von Scherler Mayer 
Writer  Neil LaBute 
Starring Adam Brody  Kristen Bell  Zoe Kazan  Mia Maestro  Jennifer Morrison 
Emily Watson  Laura Perloe  Kathleen Christy   
Studio  Leeden Media 
Review  Men usually behave badly in the works of Neil LaBute—one need only think of the cruelties that delight them in “In the Company of Men.” But in “Some Girl(s),” the one-act 2005 play that he’s adapted for the screen with director Daisy von Scherler Mayer, the main character, here called simply Man (though “Guy” is an apparent alternative), appears to be attempting some rapprochement with women that he’s wronged in the past. Of course, this is LaBute country, and all is not quite what it seems.

In Scherler Mayer’s film, Adam Brody is well cast as the fellow, capturing the character’s combination of eagerness and caginess. He’s a writer, proud of his published work, who’s about to get married to a young nurse who remains unseen through the proceedings. Apparently moved by the coming nuptials to make amends with former lovers, he travels from city to city, inviting five of them to his hotel rooms (virtually identical from place to place) to reminiscence and apologize. (The script adds the fifth woman to the four that were included in the London and New York productions of 2005-2006, as well as the Los Angeles one that followed in 2008. In some stage versions—like one by the Second Thought Theatre in Dallas in 2009—the fifth episode was included.)

The first is Sam (Jennifer Morrison), in Seattle. She’s the high school girlfriend whom he took advantage of and then dumped on the eve of their prom, and though now married she’s never forgotten his cruelty. Then comes Tyler (Mia Maestro), his free-wheeling college squeeze in Chicago, who doesn’t seem at all fazed over the fact that they split up. Next are Boston and Lindsay (Emily Watson), an uptight professor still bitter over the grad-school affair that her older husband discovered and taking a modicum of revenge for it. The fourth stop—the one omitted in the original stage productions—brings a confrontation with Reggie (Zoe Kazan), the younger sister of his best friend, who’s still obsessed with him and accuses him of having had sex with her when she was still underage. And finally there’s Bobbi (Kristen Bell) in Los Angeles, one of a pair of identical twins and perhaps the person who comes closest to being a true object of his love—but who is far more interested in deprecating his self-justification than commiserating with his increasingly obvious uncertainty about his impending marriage. Still, it’s in the course of their reunion that the real reason for the man’s journey emerges, and as usual with LaBute, it has more to do with manipulation than genuine emotion.

“Some Girl(s),” which reflects the phrase that Guy always uses to refer to other women, even the one he’s going to wed, doesn’t have the lacerating impact of LaBute’s best work. But even a minor effort like this one contributes to his perennial theme—the damage human beings (usually men, though on occasion women) can inflict on one another for their own often purely nasty ends. And though Scherler Mayer doesn’t do much to open up the piece—a few scenes on planes, in airports, and of hotel exteriors hardly mitigate the stagebound feel—she manages the individual episodes well, using close-ups and fluent camera moves to maximum effect.

And she’s chosen her cast expertly. With Brody an appropriately smarmy connecting presence, the women all make strong impressions. The most striking is Kazan, who paints a portrait of an adolescent whose life was ruined by a slightly older, more experienced boy. But Morrison, Maestro and Bell are almost equally effective. Only Watson comes off rather arch, the result more of the character than the performance. The technical credits are little more than adequate, a reflection of the modest budget, but Rachel Morrison’s cinematography uses the confined settings to good effect, and Michael Darrow’s editing brings the piece in at a crisp ninety minutes.

“Some Girl(s)” doesn’t pack the wallop of “In the Company of Men,” where one woman suffers multiple indignities rather than their being spread around among five. But even this lesser LaBute offers a nice twist to his characteristically stinging dissection of man’s inhumanity to man—and especially woman.
 

 

Copyright 2001-2009.  This material may not be reproduced or used without express permission from the author.